Return of the Jedi Deleted Scene Nearly Redeemed Obi-Wan’s Lies To Luke

The deleted dialogue from Return of the Jedi would have made Obi-Wan’s lies all of the extra tragic for Luke, with Kenobi wishing he may inform the reality to Luke.

Obi-Wan’s Misinform Luke Skywalker all through the Origins star wars seem within the trilogy return of jedic — however the deleted Yoda dialogue would have redeemed Kenobi. Darth Vader’s Revelation That He is Anakin Skywalker the Empire Strikes Again I’ve in all probability the largest plot twist star wars The franchise, nevertheless, additionally reveals that Obi-Wan (Alec Guinness) and Yoda (Frank Oz) have been mendacity to Luke (Mark Hamill) about their father. Yoda’s Strains in Scrap return of jedic The footage softened the shock a bit, nevertheless, including nuance to each of the decades-long deception of the Jedi.

ScreenRant Video of the Day

In a brand new HopeOn this episode, Luke is advised by Obi-Wan that Anakin Skywalker was a Jedi hero who was betrayed and killed by Darth Vader. the unique star wars The trilogy hadn’t been absolutely mapped out at this level, so whereas George Lucas contemplated making Darth Vader secretly Luke’s father, he would not actually canonize it till Leigh Brackett. The story’s therapy just isn’t reworked. Empire, On the behest of Richard Marquand, who had consulted a psychologist on the matter, Lucas allowed return of jedic To incorporate an extra scene on Dagoba, during which Yoda and Obi-Wan disclose to the Sith the total reality of their plan to defeat Luke.


RELATED: The Empire Strikes Again: Yoda and Obi-Wan’s Recommendation to Luke Was Horrible

Unused footage of Yoda’s dying scene return of jedic An additional layer would have been added to his and Obi-Wan’s lies. Yoda confesses to Luke, “Obi-Wan would have advised you way back, if I had let him go,” indicating that neither Jedi wished to maintain Luke at nighttime, however did so as a result of he believed it was the most effective plan of action to defeat Darth Vader and the Emperor to take action. With this extra context, Obi-Wan and Yoda’s deceit, whereas nonetheless morally questionable (provided that they have been coaching Luke to kill his father), relating to the continued failures of the Previous Jedi Each of his elements appear much more disinterested and unhappy as he speaks.


How else does Yoda’s lower ROTJ dialogue inform Obi-Wan’s lies


Yoda dies in Star Wars Return of the Jedic

Yoda, Obi-Wan and Bell Organa (Jimmy Smuts) make their long-term plan to defeat the Sith. Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith, As soon as the time is true, one or each of Anakin’s kids will probably be educated as Jedi to kill Vader and the Emperor, free the galaxy, and return to the Jedi. Sadly, the plan additionally concerned holding Luke and Leia at nighttime till the true id of their father, one thing that Yoda’s deleted dialogue signifies was not a call taken evenly.

Obi-Wan wished Luke to know the reality from the beginning, however he and Yoda could not take any possibilities to jeopardize the destiny of the galaxy. Sadly, if every thing had gone in line with plan, Luke would have realized of his true id after killing his father, which in that context can be a painful revelation. Whereas Obi-Wan and Yoda had the most effective of intentions and wished Luke to know the reality, they finally perpetuated points with their technology of Jedi.


The outdated Jedi order had an unlucky tendency to make morally questionable choices for the better good. This included recruiting potential Jedi as infants and appearing as a paramilitary pressure for the politicians of the Republic. Hiding the reality from Luke and inadvertently prompting him to commit treason was, frankly, irritating for Luke as soon as he realized the reality, return of the jedi Deleted dialogue reveals that Obi-Wan and Yoda have been finally not pleased with their actions.

NEXT: Revenge of the Jedi Reveals Anakin’s Largest Flaw (Earlier than the Prequel)

  • Rogue Squadron (2023)Launch date: December 22, 2023

Pattinson Batman needs a new batsuit

Robert Pattinson wants a brand new swimsuit for Batman 2


Concerning the Writer

Leave a Comment