Bombay HC restrains builder from creating hurdle for redevelopment of housing society in Kurla


Bombay HC restrains builder from creating hurdle for redevelopment of housing society in Kurla
| Photograph: Consultant Picture

Coming down closely on a developer who did not undertake redevelopment of a housing society in Kurla, seven years after demolishing the constructing, the Bombay Excessive Courtroom noticed that it appeared that the developer – SD Bhalerao Constructions – ‘by no means had the clear intention’ to ‘earnestly undertake the undertaking’ and full the identical.

Justice Girish Kulkarni, on July 7, restrained the developer from creating “any obstruction” from the society’s redevelopment by one other developer. The court docket has additionally directed the developer to take away all its males, supplies, and building, together with any signage or fencing/ barricades, and supplies from the positioning of Nehru Nagar Ratnadeep Co.op. Hsg. Soc. Ltd. in Kurla inside two weeks.

Whereas listening to a petition by 40 residents of the housing society, the HC noticed: “The current continuing is one other case of a co-operative housing society having 40 members who’re actually on the road. Their constructing being demolished in January 2015.”

The court docket even remarked that the developer “adopted all ways to delay the work on the undertaking”.

The constructing was constructed by MHADA in 1967. In 2009, because the constructing turned outdated and dilapidated, the society determined to redevelop the constructing.

SD Bhalerao Constructions approached the society in July 2010. Finally, on December 20, 2010 a growth settlement was signed between the society and the developer.

By Might 1, 2011, 39 members of the society vacated their tenements and just one member resisted to vacate his tenement. Lastly, a settlement was reached with him and the constructing was demolished in January 2015.

In accordance with the plea, graduation certificates was issued on April 25, 2016. “By June, 2016, a small portion of plinth was put up and since then no building by any means has taken place,” famous the HC in its 25-page order.

All this whereas, the developer even did not pay the lease quantity to the petitioners. Not simply the petitioners’ undertaking, even different tasks within the space got here to a standstill. Apart from, some FIRs have been filed towards the developer, Sanjay Bhalerao, who was arrested and thereafter launched on bail.

Lastly, the society held a particular common physique assembly on 15 January, 2021 and handed a decision to terminate the event settlement with SD Bhalerao Constructions. The discover was despatched to the developer of the identical, nevertheless, “the respondent (developer) neither responded nor challenged the termination discover and actually, has accepted the termination”, contended the plea.

Nonetheless, the developer opposed the petition contending that it is able to resolve the disputes and is keen to undertake the petitioner’s undertaking.

“In my view, the current case seems to be a gross case the place the respondent has completely did not adjust to its obligations underneath the event settlement dated 20 December, 2010,” stated the HC. it additional added: “It’s immensely disheartening that the constructing which was constructed within the yr 1967 and which was vacated on 1 Might 2011 by 39 members and subsequently demolished in January 2015, dis-housing 40 members of the society, belonging to low revenue group, is but to see even laying of a plinth. The members of the society are being made to undergo for no fault of theirs.”

The court docket even famous that the developer “was too formidable and had undertaken a number of tasks within the locality and couldn’t do justice to any of the tasks”.

“It additionally seems that the respondent has no monetary capability to undertake the undertaking and prima-facie it seems that regardless of a number of alternatives being made obtainable by the society to the respondent, the respondent couldn’t enhance its place underneath the contract, resulting in the last word termination of the contract on 03 April, 2021,” stated HC.

(To obtain our E-paper on whatsapp day by day, please click on right here. To obtain it on Telegram, please click on right here. We allow sharing of the paper’s PDF on WhatsApp and different social media platforms.)




Supply hyperlink